July-August 2008

Sustainable Stormwater

Methods of capture, treatment, and reuse

Article Tools

Create a Link to this Article

By Carol Brzozowski

Comments


“Low Impact” Versus “Sustainable”
Howe differentiates the term low-impact development (LID) as a term used by the EPA and the stormwater treatment industry and focusing primarily on stormwater issues, whereas sustainable site design is a broader term encompassing other green measures as well.

“There has to be a shift in our thinking if we are doing low-impact development or sustainable design,” says Howe. “With low-impact development, the approach to design is that, instead of considering the whole site as kind of a monolith we look at the site in its existing condition and at small areas.

“For example, you would never design a bioretention bed to treat the runoff from a 50-acre parcel; an acre or two at the most is really what we’re talking about for most of these BMPs [best management practices]. That means you usually have more BMPs on a site, but each one can be smaller and fit into the landscape better.”

For years, Coffman worked for Prince George’s County, MD, developing and promoting LID techniques. He says he did so with a thought of finding simple and inexpensive techniques that developers could use.

“It’s basically optimizing the use of the landscape to the best extent possible, and not just minimizing the impacts of stormwater runoff, but replicating the water balance,” he says. “It boils down to being more aware of how we can work with the landscape to make it work for us instead of against us.”

In pursuing LID, Coffman always considered the continued degradation of receiving waters in the Chesapeake Bay area despite the use of conventional approaches.

“If you want sustainability, you have to have technology that in some ways mimics natural ecological processes and functions that serve the receiving waters and aquatic resources in those waters,” Coffman points out.

Sustainability is becoming a more common trend in stormwater design, Howe notes. “I’ve been using LID for years, but a major thing happened a few years ago in Maine when our state’s stormwater law was changed to focus on impacts to urban-impaired streams and lakes most at risk for new development,” she says.

“The Maine Department of Environmental Protection is pushing low-impact and sustainable development by requiring quality treatment of the stormwater of any project that disturbs more than an acre, which is quite strict—it may be one of the stricter laws in the country,” says Howe, who helped to rewrite the law.

“What we are trying to do is mimic the hydrology of existing conditions in the developed conditions through the use of such things as bioretention beds, wet ponds with gravel filters, underground filtration beds, and grass swales,” she says.

One technique Howe favors is preserving existing vegetation, particularly trees. “One 50-year-old oak will take up a huge amount of stormwater in the leaves and roots,” she says.

She points out that one of the major aspects of all sustainable stormwater techniques is that “there has to be a total mind shift in how the designer thinks of the site as it fits in the larger surroundings, whether that’s the watershed or an open area. The typical practice probably most all of us did for years was building a pond—a wet pond, a dry pond, a detention area—and then piping or directing all of the stormwater runoff from the site to that pond.”

Simple approaches to sustainability include reducing impervious areas, Howe says. In one office-building project on which she is working, Howe reduced stormwater runoff by negotiating with town officials and regulators to reduce the width of the entrance, using grass for the shoulders instead of gravel or pavement, reducing the aisle width in the parking lot, and reducing the parking space length.

“A foot here, a foot there—all of these things reduce the overall impervious area on the site,” she notes.

Howe uses other approaches as well.

“A bioretention bed is depressed from the existing or finished grade no more than 6 inches, and then there is at least 18 inches of a special soil mix designed to provide the nutrients for plant growth and treat stormwater runoff—whether from a roof, parking lot, or from a road,” says Howe. “Pollutants can be hydrocarbons, heavy metals, sediments, phosphorus, and other materials.”

In some parts of the country, bioretention beds infiltrate into the ground, says Howe. In Maine and elsewhere, they infiltrate even in native soils that are clays, she says, adding that Maine has soft marine clays.

“There are places where it can’t infiltrate, so a standard cross-section for a bioretention bed often includes another layer below the filtration soil that is an underdrain. Then you outlet at some point so it does not cause erosion problems,” she explains.

The bioretention beds can be planted with grass that can withstand an inundation of stormwater and then dry out, or they can be incorporated as part of the landscape design, Howe says. She works closely with landscape architects on a project design that places bioretention beds among native shrubs, ornamentals, and ornamental grasses.

Another stormwater BMP that Howe favors is an underdrained filtration bed.

“The difference between that and bioretention is that you can have up to 18 inches of storage, but otherwise you have 18 inches below that of special filtration soil that takes out pollutants and takes up a lot of stormwater so it doesn’t actually get to the underdrain layer below that,” she says.

“Usually you detain about the 1-inch storm, and then you have an overflow so that runoff from larger storms will then bypass and leave the area.” Next Page >

What Do You Think?

Post a Comment

Be the first to tell us what you think!

Post a Comment

Not a subscriber? Sign Up
 
 
*  
 




 

Get Stormwater E-mail Updates!

Get weekly news and updates through our Stormwater e-mail newsletter!